Not sure if its lossy...

[range_hood]

I heard that some CD and flashplayers could play Atrac (3 and 3+ only). But mostly Minidisk players use the atrac codec. There is a big faq at minidisc.org.

ATRAC-Version (release year) - [bitrate] - {frequency respose}

ATRAC1-version 1.0 (1992) - [292 kbit/s] - {15kHz}
ATRAC1-version 2 (1994) - [292 kbit/s] - {18kHz}
ATRAC1-version 3 (1995) - [292 kbit/s] - {18kHz}
ATRAC1-version 3.5 (1996) - [292 kbit/s] - {18kHz}
ATRAC1-version 4 (1996) - [292 kbit/s] - {20kHz}
ATRAC1-version 4.5 (MD-Decks; 1996) - [292 kbit/s] - {20kHz}
ATRAC3-version 1.0 (MDLP) (2000) - [132/105/66 kbit/s]
ATRAC1- DSP Type-R (2001) - [292 kbit/s]
ATRAC1- DSP Type-S (2002) - [292 kbit/s]
ATRAC3plus (2003) - [256/64/48 kbit/s]

Originally Posted by Five

range_hood, is it okay if we make Minidisc atrac3 LP2/LP4 spectrals into a more generic MiniDisc SA and FA and add this pic?

Sure. Would be nice if we could gather samples of all the different versions. Should we keep that at imageshack? the maximum filesize of png files is 100kb here. I would say png are slightly better than gifs.

[ssamadhi97]

Originally Posted by range_hood

I would say png are slightly better than gifs.

That's kinda like saying "I would say flacs are slightly better than mp3s"


(actually it's more like saying "I would say flac is slightly better than adpcm", but what the heck)

[Five]

okay I'm getting the maximum filesize for .png upped asap.